The holiday season is upon us. It’s that time of year when thousands of tourists flock to New York City to walk down 5th Avenue and gaze upon the various holiday displays in shop windows. People dream of cozying up under a blanket as they take a horse-drawn carriage ride through Central Park, watching others skate on frozen ponds while sipping hot chocolate from Styrofoam cups. Indeed, it is the movie-like fantasy of experiencing the magic of New York City during the holiday season.
The reality is: ranking as the most expensive city in the United States, it’s been tough to afford accommodations in the city that never sleeps. All that changed, however, when Airbnb entered the picture. Airbnb became a beacon for short-term renters, providing an alternative option to traditional hotels, by allowing folks to visit faraway places without breaking the bank. However, New York City has now enacted Local Law 18, thus redefining how short-term rentals operate.
The ever-evolving landscape of short-term rentals, particularly through platforms like Airbnb, has sparked heated debates and legislative responses nationwide. In New York City, the focal point of this discourse is Local Law 18. This law has implications for Airbnb hosts, condo boards, apartment owners, and renters. Let’s explore the different viewpoints on Local Law 18 and what it means for the future of short-term rentals.
Background
Local Law 18 took effect on September 5, 2023. The law pertains to short-term rentals (defined as stays of less than 30 days). It allows for short-term rentals only if the host is present in the same apartment or unit at the time of the rental. “Hosts and visitors must leave the doors inside the dwelling unlocked, so occupants can access the entire unit.”
Additionally, the rental property can only permit up to two paying guests at a time. All hosts must register their apartment in New York City with the Mayor’s Office of Special Enforcement (OSE). The cost of the application is $145. Hosts are now expected to list their registration number right on their Airbnb page, making it official and aboveboard. “No number, no listing—simple as that.” Landlords who fail to abide by Local Law 18 are subject to fines ranging from $100 to $1,000 per violation.
Airbnb is outraged by Local Law 18 and is fighting the new law in the courts. Airbnb is concerned that this new law may force New York City visitors to opt for traditional hotels with less restrictive rules, rather than risk using the rental platform. Let’s breakdown the differing viewpoints and perspectives of those entrenched in this legal battle.
Airbnb’s Perspective
From Airbnb’s standpoint, Local Law 18 represents a challenging regulatory environment. The law, which restricts the duration and frequency of short-term rentals, aims to curb issues like noise disturbances and the potential transformation of residential neighborhoods into de facto hotels. Airbnb contends that it provides economic opportunities for hosts and helps tourists experience local culture authentically. However, it recognizes the need for responsible regulations to address community concerns.
For its part, in a recently dismissed suit seeking an injunction to halt the enforcement of the law, Airbnb asserted that the rules have a chilling effect on hosts simply wishing to lawfully engage in the short-term rental business. They insisted that their business would be substantially affected, claiming that losses could be as high as up to 95% of their net revenue from short-term rental listings in New York City, if they are forced to remove listings subject to the rules (due to having to remove those listings without proper verification information).
Condo Boards’ Perspectives
Condo boards tasked with maintaining the overall well-being of the condominium community often take a stance that aligns with Local Law 18’s intent. They prioritize the long-term interests of permanent residents and the preservation of a stable living environment. Condo boards may see short-term rentals as a potential source of friction within the community, leading to increased administrative burdens and potential conflicts among residents.
From the perspective of condo boards, Local Law 18 serves as a tool to regulate and control the influx of short-term guests, mitigating the potential downsides associated with transient populations. While recognizing the financial benefits for individual owners, condo boards emphasize the importance of protecting the entire community’s overall quality of life and property values.
Apartment Owners’ Perspectives
Apartment owners are a diverse group with varied perspectives on Local Law 18. Some view short-term rentals as an additional revenue stream that allows them to cover ownership costs, such as mortgages and maintenance fees. For these owners, Airbnb offers a platform to monetize their property when it would otherwise be vacant.
Conversely, there are apartment owners who oppose short-term rentals, particularly in buildings where many residents are permanent. They argue that the constant turnover of short-term guests can disrupt the sense of community and security of having long-term neighbors. The potential for wear and tear in common areas and increased noise are also concerns raised by apartment owners who prefer more traditional leasing arrangements.
Renters’ Perspectives:
Renters, especially those relying on short-term rentals through platforms like Airbnb, often appreciate the flexibility and cost-effectiveness of a platform’s offerings. From their perspective, Local Law 18 may limit their ability to rent properties for shorter durations, potentially impacting travel plans and budget considerations. Some argue that it is essential for legislators to find a middle ground that allows renters to enjoy the benefits of short-term rentals without compromising the character of residential areas.
However, some renters support the regulations imposed by Local Law 18, believing that a balance must be struck to prevent the negative externalities associated with an influx of short-term guests. Concerns about noise, safety, and the potential depletion of housing stock are valid from the renters’ standpoint. Striking the right balance between the interests of renters and the broader community remains a crucial challenge for lawmakers.
The Future of Airbnb’s Business in New York City
Local Law 18 in New York City reflects a complex interplay of interests among Airbnb, condo boards, apartment owners and renters. As the regulatory landscape continues to evolve, finding a harmonious balance between the economic opportunities afforded by short-term rentals and the need to protect the stability and character of residential communities remains a significant challenge.
Airbnb views Local Law 18 as an existential threat to its business model. Some believe the new law “is basically shutting down Airbnb” in New York City. Many people who use Airbnb often rent properties intended to hold more than two guests at a time –because more people in one unit means lower costs for each renter. With the new law only allowing for up to two people at a time (plus the addition of the host) some folks will seek out other lodgings that allow more people without the need for the presence of a host. The new Local Law 18 rules, in conjunction with escalating hotel prices, may in fact mean less people traveling to New York City to live out their holiday fantasy of spending Christmas in the Big Apple.
As New York City navigates the intricate web of short-term rental regulations, the goal should be to strike a balance that promotes both sustainable growth and community living within its diverse neighborhoods.
Interested in Other State Court Filings Involving Companies like Airbnb?
Check out Trellis! Trellis is an AI-driven, state trial court research and analytics platform. We make the fragmented US state trial court system searchable through a single interface by providing lawyers with analytical insights on judges, cases, and opposing counsel. Request a demo today and experience for yourself the ease of our analytics and API that provide you with the tools needed to streamline your legal practice.
Sources:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/travel/2023/09/01/nyc-airbnb-rules-local-law-18/
https://www.autohost.ai/new-yorks-law-18-airbnb-hosts/
Photos:
Music
Skipping by Ian Post: available at:
